Shavy It's important context that they have been in OL for the past month, immediately after they were sync stalking FWA. We agreed to share General bans, and if this appeal doesn't go through, OL shouldn't take this member. It's true that there currently is a ban sharing grace period as we reorganize and get grandfathered people through appeals, but I think that will end before three months from now.
On the case itself, I think stalking FWA should be grounds for keeping the ban from us, too. Sync stalking is sync stalking, no matter which league. However, the one month of matching OL properly and amicably for the entire time is good, and I'd call that a better show of goodwill than several months of just not sync stalking (which could just be inactivity, keep in mind). So, my opinion is that we should just unban.
That said, I don't think there will be a quick consensus here, given the opinions already expressed, so I am calling a 72h vote to resolve this appeal. (Just a reminder, please vote on this thread if you're an admin, only a max of 3 votes per league are counted, and the appeal ends when both 72h have passed and at least 5 votes have been cast.)